automatic lane centering

    One of the two primary features of Level 2 ADAS (Advanced Driver Assistance Systems) is Automatic Lane Centering (ALC) – the car's capability to steer itself in the center of a lane. Sometimes you hear people saying 'these systems are all the same'. The results here demonstrate the opposite, with some functioning impressively and others, so poorly you shouldn't consider them. 3rd-party critiques of ALC generally range from purely anecdotal comments to casually structured tests which are actually still subjective. In the last few years, Moblr has been unique in developing its own measured and reproducible ALC testing, including its methodology, test equipment, software and analysis. The test section of road we use consists of a 14-mile mix of straight and curving freeway driven at 70 mph in consistent lighting (click on the video for more). The results are boiled down to the histograms you see below; basically, bell curves showing the various places in the lane the car tends to be (the curve's peak being its most favored one). What follows are all the result's we've tested, but with the first one – for comparison – showing how a human driver (me, trying my best) performs. (In this case, you can see my left-of-center bias in the lane). This offset from the center also appears in many of the ALC examples, likely due to miscalibration of their system's camera. An optimal graph would have the vehicle's positions appear as a very narrow spike exactly in the middle of the lane; the wider and more spread-out the graph, the more the car wandered around. The associated scores are calculated by penalizing how far the data is distributed away from the lane's center. If you're interested in this data, or our ADAS-testing, drop us a message.

    automatic lane centering scores

    Click any row to highlight its score on the graph.

    Test # Make Model Score
    19AudiQ51.1
    20KiaTelluride1.4
    21VolkswagenID45.8
    22VolkswagenTiguan5.5
    23HyundaiKona EV4.1
    24KiaEV64.7
    26HyundaiTuscan PHEV4.4
    27AudiA36.6
    30VolvoXC60 Recharge T8 AWD6.1
    32VolkswagenArteon5.9
    33VolkswagenGolf R 4Motion2.4
    34VolkswagenGolf GTI6.5
    35LexusRX500h7.7
    36VolkswagenAtlas6.2
    37VolkswagenJetta GLI5.4
    40AudiQ4 etron quattro4.0
    41Hyundaiioniq 52.5
    42VolvoXC40 Recharge5.2
    43FordF150 Lightning7.5
    45ToyotaRAV4 Hybrid4.2
    46ToyotaCorolla XSE5.5
    47ToyotaGR Corolla4.5
    48HyundaiPalisade4.3
    50HyundaiSanta Cruz6.0
    53KiaEV6 GT5.6
    54AudiS74.3
    55LexusIS5008.0
    60MazdaCX90 I62.4
    61HyundaiIoniq 62.9
    63ToyotaSequioa5.8
    64MazdaCX90 PHEV3.1
    65LexusRX500h Fsport7.1
    66ToyotaPrius Prime6.1
    67LexusRZ550e7.1
    012345678910Audi Q5 — 1.1Kia Telluride — 1.4Volkswagen ID4 — 5.8Volkswagen Tiguan — 5.5Hyundai Kona EV — 4.1Kia EV6 — 4.7Hyundai Tuscan PHEV — 4.4Audi A3 — 6.6Volvo XC60 Recharge T8 AWD — 6.1Volkswagen Arteon — 5.9Volkswagen Golf R 4Motion — 2.4Volkswagen Golf GTI — 6.5Lexus RX500h — 7.7Volkswagen Atlas — 6.2Volkswagen Jetta GLI — 5.4Audi Q4 etron quattro — 4.0Hyundai ioniq 5 — 2.5Volvo XC40 Recharge — 5.2Ford F150 Lightning — 7.5Toyota RAV4 Hybrid — 4.2Toyota Corolla XSE — 5.5Toyota GR Corolla — 4.5Hyundai Palisade — 4.3Hyundai Santa Cruz — 6.0Kia EV6 GT — 5.6Audi S7 — 4.3Lexus IS500 — 8.0Mazda CX90 I6 — 2.4Hyundai Ioniq 6 — 2.9Toyota Sequioa — 5.8Mazda CX90 PHEV — 3.1Lexus RX500h Fsport — 7.1Toyota Prius Prime — 6.1Lexus RZ550e — 7.1

    score (0–10), 5 = average